Another month, another princeling fund. Okay, so they're not that prolific but there is a familiarity to PE platforms built upon the shoulders of Chinese leaders' offspring in terms of the nature of their emergence.
It starts with a whisper. In the case of Nepoch Capital - the private equity firm co-founded by the son of He Guoqiang, who stepped down from the Communist Party's highest echelon in October 2012 - the rumors began last year, months before the story made headlines last week. "There's a new princeling fund in the market, run by the son of a very senior government official," people were saying.
And once there is momentum, there is no turning back. Regardless of the GP's desire to remain below the radar, meetings must be held with potential investors. Due diligence is conducted, which includes researching the personal and professional backgrounds of key executives. The fund must also create a pipeline of investments - and maybe complete a couple of deals to impress prospective LPs - and the princeling's clout would be brought to bear when dealing with company owners and managers.
Past history also suggests that, once these funds are raised, the princeling retreats from the limelight. Winston Wen, son of former Premier Wen Jiabao, departed for a job at a state-owned enterprise within five years of - and four funds - of co-founding New Horizon Capital. Last year, Lefei Liu, who set up CITIC Private Equity in 2008, relinquished the title of chairman - although he remains CEO - ahead of his father's elevation to the Politburo Standing Committee.
It is hard to believe that a change in job title would be accompanied by the sacrifice of all economic interest in the GP or the funds it manages. It is also feasible that the princeling would quietly wield his influence on deals. Nevertheless, the timing of Nepoch's emergence is interesting: He Guoqiang is a retiring politician, not one still on the rise.
Some LPs are prone to flights of fancy when it come to China funds. If a GP has a unique selling point that suggests access to deals beyond the reach of others, warning signs in the due diligence might be overlooked. But the more experienced China investors want to see evidence of a sustainable franchise before they commit to a fund, and team stability is a key part of this.
In this respect, the cult of personality that characterizes Chinese private equity is not altogether helpful. Firms are often created on the basis of a certain individual's contacts and pedigree; they can hire all the associates they like but that person's relationship with a senior official at the China Securities Regulatory Commission, for example, is what gets portfolio companies to the front of the listing queue.
This dynamic is to be expected in an emerging market, but as a private equity firm matures its talent pool should deepen. A princeling operation therefore has a limited shelf life unless it is able to demonstrate that its competitive advantages stretch beyond nepotism.
In some cases this is already happening. New Horizon raised $1 billion for its most recent buyout fund despite Wen's departure; Boyu Capital may count Alvin Jiang, grandson of former President Jiang Zemin, among its ranks, but the firm has a strong team overall, led by ex-TPG Capital executive Mary Ma; and CITIC Private Equity has always been more than just a princeling operation, given its association with the CITIC and close ties to domestic brokerage CITIC Securities.
Nepoch is said to have received $200 million in LP commitments towards an overall target of $500 million, so the business is certain to get off the ground. Whether it gains credibility with foreign institutional investors - which remains a must if a GP is to scale up its fund sizes - remains to be seen.
Updating your subscription status
For 27 years, the AVCJ Forum has brought together leading investors from across the globe for three days of high-level dialogue, debate and networking. In a programme that combines strategic and tactical issues, you'll hear from some of the world's most successful deal makers as they share their insights on the opportunities for private equity investors going forward.
11-13 November 2014, Four Seasons Hotel, Hong Kong
With the empathic and historic victory of Narendra Modi at the recent elections in India, the market confidence has improved significantly. Until recently, India was mentioned in financial markets only in a negative light given the enormous potential and lack of delivery. Difficulties in exiting, arbitrary taxation and poor governance are just some of the chronic problems deterring investors.
Discover what repercussions the latest political developments will have on the private equity industry, the outlook for the next wave of fundraising, where GPs expect to source exits and the best way forward for existing and potential investors.
2-3 December 2014, Taj Lands End Hotel, Mumbai